
What Redundancy Mistakes Should UK Small Employers Avoid?
The owner of a small environmental consultancy has been reviewing the work coming in over the next few months. Several projects have ended, fewer new commissions are being confirmed and the business can't justify its current level of office support.
Three employees share project coordination and administration responsibilities. The owner believes the work could be managed by two people, with some duties reorganised and they already have an idea of who they'd prefer to keep. One employee has struggled with aspects of their work, another has recently returned from maternity leave and the proposed restructure may create a role with a different mix of responsibilities.
The need to reduce costs may be perfectly genuine but that doesn't automatically mean the subsequent redundancy decisions will be fair. Problems can arise when an employer struggles to explain why particular roles are affected, allows existing opinions about employees to influence selection or overlooks alternatives that might avoid dismissal.
This post is for UK SME owners and managers planning a redundancy or restructure. We'll look at some of the decisions that deserve closer examination and what you can do to avoid problems. It doesn't repeat the full redundancy procedure, which we've covered in our existing step-by-step guide.

Can you explain why these particular jobs are at risk?
It's quite possible for an owner to understand the financial pressures on their business but struggle to explain why particular jobs may need to change. Saying that costs need to come down is a starting point, but it doesn't explain to an employee why their role has been identified when they're still busy every day.
In our consultancy, the owner needs to explain what's changed in the available work. Perhaps fewer environmental surveys and assessments are being commissioned, which means less project scheduling and report administration. Some work will remain but there won't be enough to justify the existing headcount. Employees should be able to understand why the proposal is to reduce three positions to two, particularly when they can still see plenty of work being done.
An SME doesn't need an elaborate financial presentation but it does need an explanation that can stand up to reasonable questions. The owner should be able to show which projects have ended, what work is expected over the coming months and why the proposed staffing reduction is necessary. If employees point out that the team is still busy, they should be able to distinguish a current backlog from the amount of work expected in future. It's also worth explaining whether other ways of reducing costs have been considered and why this team is affected.
Employees may have information the owner hasn't fully considered. For example, they might point out that a client contract is likely to be renewed or that some administration is essential to meeting contractual requirements. Meaningful consultation allows the business to examine those points before making final decisions. The employer doesn't have to agree with every suggestion but they should investigate anything that could affect the proposal, explain their conclusions and be prepared to reconsider where necessary.
Are performance concerns influencing who you want to make redundant?
The consultancy owner has been concerned for some time about one employee's missed deadlines. They may understandably think that, if one position has to go, it makes sense to retain the people who are performing more strongly. However, there are two separate questions to consider. Does the business genuinely need fewer employees to carry out the work? And, if it does, how will it decide fairly who is affected?
If the business still needs the same number of employees and the real objective is to remove someone whose performance hasn't improved, redundancy isn't the appropriate route. The employer should deal with those concerns through the relevant performance or capability process.
But where there's a genuine reduction in the requirement for employees, performance can legitimately be considered as part of a fair selection exercise. The difficulty comes when an existing frustration with an employee starts influencing decisions that should be based on the needs of the business.
Because all three employees in our consultancy undertake overlapping work, the owner should consider whether they belong in the same selection pool. Different job titles don't necessarily mean employees carry out substantially different duties. The employer needs to consider the work people actually do and whether their skills are sufficiently interchangeable, then be able to explain why particular employees have been included or excluded.
Any performance scores also need supporting evidence. Suppose the employee who's missed deadlines has regularly been waiting for technical information from consultants before they can complete their reports. That context could make a significant difference to how their performance should be assessed.
Criteria such as flexibility and adaptability can create similar difficulties. What does flexibility actually mean for the future role and how will it be measured? If one employee receives a lower score because they don't regularly work beyond their contracted hours, the employer needs to consider whether that's a fair and relevant measure.
There may also be discrimination risks. A requirement to change working hours at short notice could disadvantage employees with caring responsibilities and potentially amount to indirect sex discrimination unless objectively justified. Criteria may also disadvantage disabled employees or those who have been absent for pregnancy or maternity-related reasons. Employers should consider whether the requirement is genuinely necessary and whether there's a fairer way to assess the skills or availability needed.
Ultimately, the employer should be able to explain the selection criteria and show how the scores were reached using reliable evidence. An employee may still disagree with the outcome but they should be given enough information to understand the reasoning and challenge any factual errors or inconsistencies in their own scores.

Have you assumed an employee wouldn't want another role?
As the consultancy works through its proposed structure, the owner identifies a new position combining project coordination with responsibilities previously undertaken elsewhere in the business. They assume one of the affected employees won't be interested because they've previously expressed a preference for their existing work.
It's an understandable assumption but the employee may feel differently when the alternative is redundancy. They might be willing to learn additional responsibilities or accept different working arrangements if they're given a proper explanation of what's involved.
Employers should identify all available vacancies and discuss them with employees at risk of redundancy, rather than concentrating only on roles that closely resemble their existing jobs. An employee may be interested in a position with different responsibilities, reduced hours or a different level of seniority. As a practical approach, the business should give affected employees an opportunity to consider vacancies before looking to recruit externally.
There is an important distinction between making employees aware of vacancies and the legal duty to offer suitable alternative employment. Where a vacancy is suitable for an employee facing redundancy, the employer should make an appropriate offer rather than simply expecting them to compete through an ordinary recruitment process. Suitability depends on the circumstances, including duties, skills, pay, working hours, location and other terms.
If several affected employees are suitable for one vacancy and there aren't enough positions available, it may be necessary to conduct a fair selection exercise, subject to the additional priority rights discussed below.
An SME may have very few vacancies but it's important that employees have the opportunity to consider what's available rather than managers deciding on their behalf what they would or wouldn't accept.
Have you checked the protections for pregnant employees and new parents?
One of the consultancy employees has recently returned from maternity leave. The owner needs to check whether she's still within the redundancy protected period, which normally continues until 18 months after the child's birth. Protection also applies during pregnancy once the employer has been notified and there are similar rights for employees taking adoption leave and certain other types of family leave.
These protections don't prevent a genuine redundancy. If the consultancy is reducing three existing positions to two, the employee can still take part in a fair selection exercise. Where the business is simply reducing the number of existing posts without creating new roles, the remaining positions aren't automatically suitable alternative vacancies.
However, if the restructure creates a new role or another suitable vacancy becomes available, the position is different. An employee within the protected period must be offered a suitable alternative vacancy as a priority over employees without that protection. If more than one protected employee is suitable and there aren't enough vacancies, the employer may need to make a fair selection between them.
This means the owner needs to consider carefully whether the proposed combined role is a suitable alternative vacancy for the employee who's returned from maternity leave, rather than simply applying the normal selection arrangements.
There's also a separate financial point that often causes confusion. Redundancy doesn't normally remove an employer's obligation to pay Statutory Maternity Pay (SMP) once the employee has qualified for it.
An employee can be made redundant during pregnancy, provided the redundancy is genuine and the employer meets its legal obligations. If they've already qualified for SMP, the employer will generally remain responsible for paying it even after their employment ends. It's important to check the employee's entitlement rather than assume that ending their employment also brings maternity payments to an end.
Before confirming the redundancy decision
For larger SMEs, there's another issue to check as early as possible. Where an employer proposes 20 or more redundancies at one establishment within a 90-day period, statutory collective consultation and notification requirements apply. These involve employee representatives and minimum timescales, so businesses approaching that threshold should take advice before setting their timetable. Voluntary redundancies and employees who may ultimately be redeployed can still count towards the proposed numbers.
Whatever the scale of the exercise, employers also need to follow a fair process, comply with relevant policies, consider alternatives and deal correctly with notice, redundancy payments where due and appeals. Our existing guide to managing redundancies in a small business covers those steps in more detail.
A genuine need to reduce costs doesn't remove the need to make fair decisions about the people affected. Taking time to examine those decisions before they're finalised can help employers avoid mistakes that are much harder to resolve afterwards.
Disclaimer
This article provides general information and practical guidance for employers in Great Britain. It isn't legal advice and shouldn't replace advice on specific employment circumstances. Different rules apply in Northern Ireland.
